Which Is Better, Water Shoes or Sandals?

Woman hiker hiking on seaside trail

Table of Contents

Water shoes or sandals are popular for those who love being around water, such as beachgoers or those who enjoy spending time on the lake. 

However, each of these footwear options has its unique pros and cons, so choosing the right one depends on what kind of activity you plan to do and the conditions that you will be in.

Each option offers different benefits when it comes to water shoes vs. sandals. Water shoes provide more support and protection than traditional sandals because they are designed with a closed toe and a better grip sole that helps keep your feet from slipping when walking on wet surfaces.

They also provide added cushioning, which is great for standing on hard surfaces for long periods, such as rocks or coral reefs. However, water shoes can also be quite heavy and may not be suitable if you are going to be swimming for extended periods.

Sandals, on the other hand, provide less coverage and protection than water shoes but still offer some advantages over barefooting. Sandals come with straps that secure your feet in place and make them ideal for activities like kayaking or canoeing, where little foot movement is needed. 

Additionally, they are much lighter than water shoes which makes them perfect for warm weather days when your feet need to breathe. 

While sandals don’t offer as much traction as water shoes do, they are still an upgrade over going barefoot, which can leave you vulnerable to sharp objects in the water, such as glass or metal debris.

Ultimately, what type of shoe best relies on personal needs and preferences and the environment you will be in.

For example, if you plan to spend most of your time in the pool or ocean, then a pair of waterproof sandals or water shoes both work just fine, giving you adequate protection from sharp objects below while keeping your feet comfortable too. 

On calmer waters like rivers and lakes, however, where there isn’t much risk of stepping on anything dangerous, going barefoot might even suffice.

When Should You Wear Water Shoes?

Water shoes should be worn in any situation where you anticipate being exposed to sharp objects that can potentially injure your feet.

This could include paddling through rocky creeks or snorkeling in shallow, coral-filled waters. Water shoes are also great for those who spend much time on their feet around the pool deck and need extra protection from slipping.

When Should You Wear Sandals?

Sandals are great for activities that require minimal foot movements, such as canoeing or kayaking. They also work well in warm climates where your feet need to breathe without sacrificing protection from sharp objects in the water. 

Additionally, if you tend to get hot easily and don’t want extra insulation from water shoes, then sandals can help keep your feet cool.

In addition, sandals are lightweight and much easier to carry around than water shoes, making them perfect for day trips or hikes to the beach, where you’ll need something that won’t weigh you down.

Are Water Shoes Good for Your Feet?

Water shoes can provide excellent protection and support for your feet, especially when walking on wet surfaces or stepping on sharp objects.

They are designed with a closed toe, which helps to keep your feet safe from injuries, as well as added cushioning that provides additional comfort when standing for long periods.

In addition, many water shoes come with a better grip sole that helps to prevent slipping when walking on wet surfaces, making them perfect for activities such as paddleboarding or snorkeling.

Water shoes can offer great support and protection for your feet while also providing comfort and traction. As long as you choose the right type depending on your needs, they can be an excellent choice to wear in and around the water.

Are There Any Disadvantages to Wearing Water Shoes Instead of Sandals?

Water shoes are generally more expensive than sandals, so if you’re on a budget, this may not be the best option. Further, they tend to be much heavier, which can make them uncomfortable to wear for extended periods.

Moreover, some people find that water shoes don’t provide enough ventilation and can cause their feet to get hot and sweaty.

It’s best to consider both options carefully before making a decision and choose the one that best fits your needs and preferences.  No matter which shoe you wear, make sure it is comfortable and offers enough protection for your feet when in or around the water.  

That way, you can enjoy a safe and enjoyable experience without worries. But, of course, water shoes and sandals both have their pros and cons, depending on the situation.

What Type of Terrain Is Best Suited for Sandals, and Which One Is Better in Wet Conditions?

Sandals are the better option for flat, dry terrain since they provide little to no cushioning or protection and can be uncomfortable on rocky ground. However, they are ideal in warm climates where your feet need to breathe and during activities that require minimal foot movements.

When it comes to wet conditions, water shoes offer more traction and protection compared to sandals. They are designed to protect your feet from sharp objects and slippery surfaces, making them the ideal choice for activities such as swimming or snorkeling.

It is essential to consider both options carefully before making a decision, depending on the terrain you’ll be walking on and the type of activity you are doing. That way, you can make the most of your time enjoying the water!

It is also important to remember that sandals and water shoes have advantages and disadvantages. Sandals are lightweight and designed for minimal foot movements, whereas water shoes offer added protection and support against slippery surfaces or sharp objects in the water. 

Therefore, it is crucial to consider your specific needs before deciding on which type of shoe is the best option for you.  

No matter what you choose, ensure it is comfortable and provides enough protection for your feet in or around the water. That way, you can have a safe and enjoyable experience without worries.      


There is no one answer to the question of which is better, water shoes or sandals. Both options have their benefits and drawbacks depending on the situation.

More Of The Same Category​

Jenny Schmidt

Jenny Schmidt

As an avid swimmer and kayak lover for decades, I know how important it is to get the right shoes to keep your feet healthy.
I'll let you in on some secrets only a few know...

About Me

As an avid swimmer and kayak lover for decades, I know how important it is to get the right shoes to keep your feet healthy.
I’ll let you in on some secrets only a few know…

Recent Posts

Weekly Reviews